Protests Involving Government Failure to Reconcile Evaluations

Government agencies may issue multiple solicitations for similar or related procurements, with the same offerors responding to each. In such situations, each procurement stands on its own, and the evaluation ratings a procuring agency assigns under one solicitation are not probative of the alleged unreasonableness of the ratings under another. Thus, contractors who submit proposals under multiple similar procurements are not entitled to expect identical ratings to those of past procurements, even when their current …